Shoppers Say This ‘Long-Lasting’ $8 Lipstick Shade Is ‘Comparable to MAC's Russian Red’

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.

There are a lot of strong opinions on the perfect universal red lip shade, but there seems to be one through-line: MAC Cosmetics delivers when it comes to red lipsticks, especially with Russian Red. The cult-favorite, rich, medium-dark red with subtle blue undertones has won over fans looking for a slightly deeper shade than Ruby Woo.

Still, even the most devoted MAC loyalists find themselves searching for an option that doesn’t cost $25 a tube. That’s where Maybelline’s Super Stay 2-Step Liquid Lipstick in Keep It Red comes in. The $8 liquid lipstick has quickly earned a reputation as a budget-friendly alternative — and judging by the rave reviews, it’s well-deserved.

Fans can’t get over how this red liquid lipstick manages to stay put through it all. We’re talking pasta dinners, long workdays, and yes, even late-night snack runs. As one reviewer shared, “This stuff is crazy! It truly does not come off! I applied it in the early afternoon and ate, drank, went about my day, and it was still looking good by bedtime.” The secret weapon? Maybelline’s clever Micro Flex technology, which helps the lipstick glide on like a gloss, set like a stain, and moisturize like a balm — all while staying in place.

And Keep It Red’s rich tone is winning serious luxury beauty comparisons. One shopper swooned, “I got the Keep It Red color and it’s a gorgeous and bright classic red. More of a cooler red than a warm red, but very bold. Comparable to MAC’s Russian Red.”

The bold red lipstick’s formula is a standout, too. With a two-step application that includes a precision-tip applicator and an ultra-conditioning balm, it’s designed to keep lips smooth and hydrated all day. As one longtime user shared, “This lipstick stays on all day, even when eating. It feels smooth and goes on effortlessly. The clear cover also gives it a nice shine. It does not dry my lips.”

Even seasoned beauty lovers are finding clever ways to maximize it. One reviewer shared that she applies a matte lipstick over Keep It Red while it’s still drying, creating a custom, locked-in color cocktail that lasts through meals and wipes. Her verdict? It “works very well as a base for several iconic reds like MAC Russian Red, Urban Decay Bad Blood, or NYX Perfect Red.”

Bottom line? If you want bold, long-lasting color that earns real-world praise — without the $25 price tag — maybe it’s time to give Maybelline 2-Step Super Stay Liquid Lipstick in Keep It Red a try. At only $8 a tube, why not try out a couple of shades?

Before you go, check out our slideshow below: