Short-term rentals are now illegal in Saratoga
The Saratoga City Council decided to explicitly outlaw short-term rentals in the city on Jan. 21.
The law that the council approved does not allow for short-term rentals of residences, like those listed on Airbnb or VRBO. The council also set penalties for people found to be listing their homes for short-term tenants. A first warning would cost $1,500, which would increase to $3,000 at the second warning, a third warning would incur a fine of $5,000. The law also allows the city to request data from websites for short-term rental listings for enforcement reasons.
Community development director Bryan Swanson estimated that permitting short-term rentals could raise between $60,000 and $80,000 each year. However, the city may only see half of that revenue due to enforcement costs, city manager Matt Morley said. Swanson said it may cost $5,000-$10,000 annually to pay for a tech company to scour the internet for listings in Saratoga.
Swanson said putting the prohibition into law would give either city code enforcement staff or officers with the county sheriff’s department the ability to penalize rental operators. City attorney Richard Taylor added that the law was necessary because it is hard to enforce short-term rentals without data from rental websites or a service that could detect them on the internet.
A handful of residents spoke up against allowing short-term rentals, citing safety concerns due to parking, trash and noise.
The law passed in a 4-1 vote, with Councilmember Belal Aftab dissenting. Councilmember Yan Zhao proposed the motion to ban short-term rentals, and Vice Mayor Tina Walia seconded it. Zhao said short-term rentals do not fit with Saratoga’s character, which mostly made up of single-family homes meant for long-term living. She also said she was concerned about safety, noise and quality of life.
In his dissent, Aftab suggested allowing short-term rentals in bedrooms or accessory dwelling units where the owner is home to address loneliness among seniors and give those with fixed incomes a secondary source of money. He said it was unlikely that investors would buy homes in Saratoga to turn into short-term rentals because of the high home prices in the area.