Is Quince worth it? Our style editors put its viral clothing and home goods to the test

I'm all about having a unique selection of different knit sweaters for the winter, but if there's one basic style I have to have in my closet, it's a black turtleneck. I can dress it up or down and it makes for a great base layer. With matching black jeans, a black turtleneck goes well with almost any combination of jacket, shoes, and hat. This past winter season, Quince's Mongolian Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater was my go-to.

When it comes to cashmere, I'm less concerned about the brand name and more about the quality of the materials. After all, you'll never see the branding, but the material is what's next to your skin. Made from 100% Grade A Mongolian Cashmere, I didn't have any issues wearing Quince's Cashmere sweater directly on my skin for hours at a time. 

I've come across quite a few sweaters in the same price range — some for even less — but they're notoriously itchy. At that point, they're not worth the savings.  — Amir Ismael, senior reporter, Insider Reviews

Read more in our full Quince cashmere review.

This slouchy, casual-but-polished sweater has become my go-to for Zoom calls. The fit is perfectly oversized — I'm usually between a small and a medium in tops and the S/M fits me well with room to spare — which makes it great for layering on top of a long-sleeve shirt or tank. Thanks to the longer tunic-style length, it looks great with a pair of leggings or jeans but can also be worn over a midi skirt for a more elevated look. — Talia Ergas, freelance writer, Insider Reviews

I've long searched for the perfect white button-up, but of the ones I've tried, many were just too see-through. For that reason, I was skeptical about trying this blouse in white, but I was impressed at how opaque it was, only showing the faintest outline of my tan bra in certain spots. Still, it felt polished enough to wear in a business setting if you're intent on finding where to shop for women's workwear clothes. 

I sized up to a medium (I'm usually in between small and medium in tops), which was a good choice. The fit is roomy and relaxed but not oversized. It looks great tucked into a pair of high-waisted jeans or layers nicely under Quince's Baby Alpaca Wool Cropped Sweater. Like the skirt, the washable silk blouse comes in fifteen colors. — Talia Ergas, freelance writer, Insider Reviews

Read more in our full Quince washable silk review. 

I'm allergic to wool, so every time I find an oversized cotton sweater or cardigan, I get extra excited. After testing this one from Quince, I consider the brand a top selection for the best sweaters for women and am definitely planning to buy it in more colors! I love the swingy, oversized fit, and the weight of it is substantial enough that I don't worry about it stretching or shrinking.  — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

This one might be my absolute favorite sweater that I own. Originally, I was drawn to the ivory version, but then I read reviews of the white colorway being a bit see-through, so I chose the similar light gray version instead. I love that I can wear this cardigan totally on its own, or layer it over a collared blouse or basic tee. Its oversized buttons give it a nice vintage feel, as if it came straight from grandpa's closet, but its blouson sleeves modernize and elevate the look.

Although the cardigan is described as cropped on the website, for me, it hit right at the top of my hips (and I have a longer torso), so semi-cropped might be a more accurate descriptor. The best part: it's snuggly warm and not even remotely itchy. I have never been able to wear a wool sweater without a tank underneath due to the itching, but this one made it possible. — Talia Ergas, freelance writer, Insider Reviews

I was hoping Quince's Flowknit fabric would feel similar to some of my other favorites from Vuori or Outdoor Voices — and indeed, it did. Quince's version is still buttery soft and super stretchy, but it's much more affordable than its competitors. This heathered hoodie is perfect for both workouts and running errands.

I love the thumb loops and the sleeves are extra-long, which is great for me since I'm 5'7", but I imagine they might be a bit too long for more petite people. My only wish is that Quince offered it in more colors to match more of their Ultra-Soft Performance Leggings, because the two make such a cute set. — Talia Ergas, freelance writer, Insider Reviews

Of all the best cashmere sweaters we've tested, Quince has my favorite affordable options. This style isn't necessarily as chunky as you'd expect from a classic fisherman's sweater, but the density is still plenty enough to stay warm with. I've worn mine all winter long (even to bed) because it's so soft and comfortable. It fit me true to size, though next time I'd size up so the sleeves can fall further past my wrists. — Gabrielle Chase, associate style editor, Insider Reviews

A silk skirt is such a versatile wardrobe staple. It pairs well with sneakers and a t-shirt or slouchy sweater for a casual ensemble or can be worn with heels and a matching silky camisole for a dressy evening look. I was super excited to try Quince's version, which comes in an impressive range of nine colors.

This skirt, which hits just below the knees, did not disappoint. I'm currently between a medium and a large in bottoms, and sizing up to a large ended up being the right call. The elastic waistband falls loosely at my hips and the skirt is plenty flowy, so it doesn't show any panty lines.  — Talia Ergas, freelance writer, Insider Reviews

These pants were truly the only miss of the bunch for me, and I think it had more to do with the color than the execution. The pants themselves are super lightweight and great to throw on over a swimsuit for a pool day, but the white color (which looked more beige on the site) is stark and sheer. The elastic waist at least gives you some flexibility in terms of sizing, plus it makes the pants extra comfy.  — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

These moisture-wicking leggings are made from approximately seven recycled water bottles each, which you wouldn't expect based on how soft and stretchy they feel. The pants, available in 11 colors, have a 25-inch inseam and a super high waist. I wore them cycling and they stayed put throughout my entire workout. They're the perfect partner for the Pullover Hoodie above. — Talia Ergas, freelance writer, Insider Reviews

Quince Organic Heavyweight Fleece Crew

Quince Organic Heavyweight Fleece Jogger

Some might consider sweatsuits to be activewear, but for me, it's just something easy and comfortable to throw on when I don't need to be dressed for a particular occasion. Over the years, I've tested well over a dozen sweatsuits from different brands and Quince is one of the best — the price makes it even better. If I had to guess the MSRP on the crewneck sweatshirt and fleece jogger before knowing how affordable the brand is, I would've said $80 each.

Both the top and bottom are made of 375g heavyweight organic cotton fleece, which makes them warmer and softer than most other options at this price. Smaller details like metal tips on the drawstrings and a hidden zippered smartphone pocket also make the set feel very premium.

I could have gone with a size small for a better fit, but I prefer the extra space of the size medium. And don't worry about the wrinkles; I've been wearing this set strictly for comfort.   — Amir Ismael, senior reporter, Insider Reviews

The midi-length counterpart to the Mongolian Cashmere Turtleneck dress is a solid option if you want a dress with more coverage. The fit is slightly roomy in the middle, so it's best to size down if you want a more sleek look. Otherwise, if you have a statement belt you've been wanting to break out, you can wear it to draw in the waist on this dress. 

"The turtleneck is high enough to reach my chin so it's a great option for keeping warm while still looking polished. It has side slits to allow my legs to move easily, and the 47" length hits me a bit past my knees."— Gabrielle Chase, associate style editor, Insider Reviews

A winter dress as comfy as it is warm, Quince's cashmere turtleneck frock (available in five cozy hues) is a great dressier staple for colder months. My body is pear-shaped, and even though I sized up to a large, the dress was still very fitted around my bottom half, so I probably wouldn't choose this one first for professional settings. Still, it's a great piece to throw on with a pair of calf-height heel boots for an evening out. — Talia Ergas, freelance writer, Insider Reviews

If you're looking for a cozy throw-on outfit, I highly recommend this jumpsuit. Though the legs were a bit long on my 5'1" frame, the jumpsuit fit like a dream — just roomy enough to layer a turtleneck underneath on chillier spring days, but not so oversized that I couldn't just wear it on its own without my bra showing. The linen isn't particularly hefty, but in the black color, it remains totally opaque.  — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

I love the simplicity of this tank dress, but the high slit gives it a flirty feel that elevates it a bit. I found the material to be ever-so-slightly sheer when I bent over, so I recommend sizing up for a little extra give when you bend or move around. I opted for a large, which is my usual size, but I could have gone up to the XL for a bit more room. — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

This organic cotton poplin dress is a great dupe for the popular Somerset dress from Anthropologie at less than half the price. It comes in black and this bright reddish-orange color, and while the cotton material has no stretch, the dress has elastic at the waist for flexibility with the sizing. On the model, it hits mid-calf, but on my 5'1" frame, it was a full-length maxi dress. I'll definitely be wearing this on date nights and warm weather outings! — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

Quince SuperSoft Fleece Crew

Quince SuperSoft Fleece Pants

During the pandemic, we wrote a lot about the best loungewear you can buy, so I tested probably 10-15 lounge sets while working from home. I wish I had known about this set sooner, because it's definitely my new favorite! 

The material is relatively thin and lined with a supersoft fleece that feels like you're wearing a cloud. The wide-leg pants fell in just the right place on my calf, and I love that they're versatile enough to pair with other tops besides the matching sweatshirts. The crew fit really well, and though it wasn't cropped by design, it tucked into the high-waisted pants without billowing out too much.  It took two or three washes to stop seeing little bits of fuzz lingering behind on the inside, so I recommend putting it through the laundry before your first wear.  — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

Leather shirt jackets are a wardrobe staple that can carry you through every season, and this one from Quince is a really affordable option — though there are some clear reasons why. While it's made from real leather, most of the paneling inside of the shirt is unlined. That means the underside of the leather is exposed, so I can tell just how thin it is. However, it doesn't affect the look of the shirt, so I still think it's a good value for anyone who isn't into synthetic leather but also doesn't want to pay $300+ for a piece like this.

In terms of sizing, the sleeves run a little long, but the body of the jacket is true to size. It comes in this mushroom beige as well as black, and it looks super effortless when paired with a T-shirt and some jeans or wide-leg pants. — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

I've always liked the look of suede bombers, but as someone who owns so many other jackets, it's been hard to justify spending a significant amount of money on a style I didn't necessarily need and would only wear once in a blue moon. 

Even if your reasoning isn't the same as mine, the fact of the matter is that a quality suede jacket can easily run you $700, if not more. I received the Suede Bomber for the purpose of this Quince review, but I definitely would pay the $150 price tag for it — and I still might grab another in a different colorway (such as their black or brown). It's made from 100% top-grain goat suede leather and it feels like it could be sold for at least three or four times the asking price. After trying it out, it promptly earned a spot in our guide to the best bomber jackets for men.

The jacket runs true to size, but don't be afraid to size up for a roomier fit. The models on the site are listed as being 6'0" and 6' 1" wearing a medium; I'm 5 '5 ", and the medium also fits me nicely. — Amir Ismael, senior reporter, Insider Reviews

I am a huge fan of Quince's underwear. I helped to test undies for our guide to the best underwear for women and genuinely thought Tommy John was unbeatable — until I tried Quince's undies. The Second Skin material is super airy and lightweight, similar to Tommy John's Air Mesh underwear. I've tried the thongs and briefs, as well as the Scoop-Neck Bralette and the Crossover Bralette all  in the Second Skin material, and I really like how breathable the material is. Of the bras, I preferred the scoop-neck style because I have DDD cups that couldn't be contained by the crossover style, but keep in mind that this material is very thin so it's not meant to be exceptionally supportive.The MicroModal material is also incredibly comfortable and slightly thicker, so I prefer wearing those pairs with jeans. It feels almost identical to my Tommy John underwear, with a comfortable elastic waistband that doesn't dig in whatsoever. I will probably only be buying my underwear from Quince from now on. Sorry, Tommy John!  — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

Some sports bras are meant for exercising, and some are just meant for lounging around. This one is definitely the latter. The soft material feels nice on the skin and the compression is low to medium, so it's cozy for wearing around the house while working from home or lounging on the couch. You could probably get away with wearing this to a low-intensity yoga class, especially if you have a small chest, but I wear a 36DD bra so I need much more support and compression for exercising. I opted for the XL size and it fits my cups well, though since I have a short torso, the straps are a little long on me. Regardless this has become my go-to for days spent at home.  — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

This scarf is hands down my most-worn accessory this winter. It's warm, extremely soft, and the perfect length to wrap around my neck when it gets windy outside. I chose the burgundy color which has since run out of stock, but it's currently still available in black, gray, brown, and navy. Despite being lightweight, this scarf still feels insulating, and I've found it easy to roll up and stow away in my purse. — Gabrielle Chase, associate style editor, Insider Reviews

I am absolutely obsessed with these shearling mini boots. They look just like the mini UGGs, but come at half the price. After wearing them for a while, I can tell that the quality of their construction isn't quite as nice as the name-brand version — for example, there have been a few loose threads in the stitching and the soles are just flat foam — but honestly, I'm not mad about it for the price. I got my usual size and they fit perfectly, but I'd recommend sizing up if you usually wear a half size since they only carry whole sizes.  — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

The quilted leather camera bag is such a good everyday staple that's easy to dress up or down. At 6 x 8.5 x 3 inches, it's more spacious than it looks, and I can easily fit my large wallet, sunglasses, phone, keys, and even a purse-shaped water bottle inside. In terms of appearance, it's comparable to the ultra-popular Saint Laurent Lou quilted camera bag, but of course, it comes at a very small fraction of the price. For 100% top-grain Italian leather, the price tag is unbeatable.  — Talia Ergas, freelance writer, Insider Reviews

With a shape that's reminiscent of a Birkin, it's obvious that this bag from Quince is a timeless hit. Its structured body and clever internal organization make it our top pick for a day-to-night satchel among the best work bags for women, but it's also just a cute purse for any occasion. I love that it has both a top handle and a cross-body/shoulder strap to make it easier to carry when it's loaded with my laptop and charger. I don't dislike the cognac color of the bag I got, but I do think it would look even better in black. I like to style mine with a silk scarf wrapped around the straps for an elegant twist.   — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

Ever since I put this blanket on our couch, my partner and I have been fighting over who gets to use it. We each like to sit at the corners of the couch so it doesn't reach us both at the same time, but if we cuddle up together, the large size keeps us both completely covered and cozy. It's a great dupe for the pricier versions from Pottery Barn, which cost about double the amount. The material is incredibly soft and silky and nicely weighted — I'll definitely be buying these as gifts during the holidays this year!  — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

The bedding I originally tested was the Luxe Italian Satin Stitch Sheet Set, which has since been phased out in favor of a similar version, the Classic Organic Percale Piped Sheet Set. The quality of Quince's percale sheets rivals that of brands like Brooklinen and Boll and Branch (both of which I own and can personally attest to). You can hardly tell a difference besides Brooklinen's equivalent being $50 more. Quince's sheets are silky, cool to the touch, and don't feel thin or flimsy. Each one comes with two pillowcases, a fitted sheet, and a top sheet, with the one downside being that top-sheet haters can't purchase a la carte. My wife and I stay cool throughout the night in Quince's sheets, and they make our bed feel like we're sleeping in a fancy hotel.  — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

Unfortunately, Quince's size offerings are not very size-inclusive, with the majority of their clothing ranging from XS-XL in women's and S-XL in men's. Some of their pants do offer different inseam lengths, although it's not as far reaching as we'd hoped. For our next Quince review, we'd like to see the brand offer extended sizes, including petite and tall options.

If you're looking for timeless wardrobe staples in top-notch fabrics such as cashmere, silk, and organic cotton, Quince offers an excellent selection at a more affordable price point than its competitors. We were impressed with the material quality and how each style flatters the wearer.